Broken link building: find dead links, offer a replacement, earn the link

By the Backlink Gap team · November 10, 2026 · 4 min read

Short answer: broken link building means finding pages that link to something that no longer exists, then offering the site owner your page as a replacement. It works because you fix a real problem on their page: their readers are clicking into a dead end. It only works if your page genuinely covers what the dead page covered.

Why it works

Every site accumulates dead links: articles get deleted, businesses close, sites change their URLs without redirects. A page full of broken links serves its readers badly. When you point out a broken link and offer a good replacement, you’re doing the editor a favour, which is a much better opening than asking for one.

Step 1: Find dead resources in your topic

Three practical ways:

  1. Your competitors’ dead pages. Competitors move and delete pages too. A backlink tool that lists their links with the target URLs lets you spot targets that no longer load.
  2. Resource pages in your field. Pages titled “resources”, “useful links” or “further reading” are often old and full of dead links. Click through them.
  3. Your backlink gap. The sites that link to your competitors and not to you (free check) often link to several resources in your topic, so it’s worth checking their pages for dead ones.

Open the target URL yourself. It counts as broken if it returns a “not found” error, a server error, or redirects to an unrelated home page. Check twice on different days; sites go down temporarily.

Step 3: Find out what the dead page said

You can only offer a replacement if you know what you’re replacing. The Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine often has copies: enter the dead URL, pick a date on the calendar (blue dots are successful captures, per the Archive’s help pages) and read what was there. The Archive warns that some pages were never captured or were excluded, so not every dead page can be recovered.

Step 4: Make sure your page is a real replacement

Compare honestly:

  • Does your page cover the same question, at least as well?
  • Is it current?
  • Would the linking page’s readers be happy to land on it?

If not, either improve your page first or skip that opportunity. Offering a loosely related page is how broken link outreach turns into spam.

Step 5: Find the right contact

Look for a contact page, an “about” page or a role address on the site’s own domain (editor@, contact@). If the page has an author, their author page may say how to reach them. Use what the site publishes.

Step 6: Write a short, specific email

Point out the broken link first, then offer your page as one option:

Subject: Broken link on your [topic] page

Hi [Name], on [page URL] the link to “[anchor]” returns an error. If you need a replacement, [your URL] covers the same thing: [one line]. Happy to suggest another source if ours isn’t a fit.

See more in our outreach email templates. Include your postal address and an opt-out line if the email is commercial; in the US, the FTC’s CAN-SPAM guide applies to business email too.

Step 7: Keep a simple tracker

For each opportunity: linking page, dead URL, your replacement, contact, date sent, reply. Follow up once after a week, then move on.

A worked example

A garden centre finds that a regional gardening blog’s “planting calendar resources” page links to a council leaflet that now returns “not found”. The Wayback Machine shows the leaflet was a month-by-month planting table for the region. The garden centre already publishes an up-to-date planting calendar for the same area, so it writes to the blog’s editor, names the dead link, and offers its calendar as one possible replacement. The match is genuine, which is why the request makes sense.

How many to send

Broken link outreach works best in small, careful batches. Ten well-matched opportunities, each checked by hand, usually beat a hundred loosely matched ones. Track replies per batch and tighten your matching if few editors answer.

Things to avoid

  • Asking for a specific keyword anchor. Google’s link guidance favours descriptive, natural anchor text; let the editor choose.
  • Offering payment. Google’s spam policies treat paying for links that pass ranking credit as link spam.
  • Creating thin “replacement” pages at scale. Google’s spam policies also cover scaled content made mainly to manipulate rankings.

Common mistakes

  • Reporting links that work (check twice).
  • Offering a page that doesn’t match what was linked.
  • Writing a long email. The editor needs the broken URL and your suggestion, nothing more.

FAQ

Is broken link building still worth it? When the replacement is genuinely good, yes: it solves a visible problem for the site owner. When the match is weak, it’s just another cold pitch.

Should I recreate the dead page? Only if the topic belongs on your site and you can do it better and honestly, in your own words.

How do I find broken links on a page quickly? Open the page and click its outbound links, or use a link checker on that page. Confirm each broken link yourself before you write.

What if the site never replies? Follow up once after a week, then move on. Keep the opportunity in your tracker in case the page is updated later.

Sources

Keep reading